Monday, September 26, 2005

from "Fontanelles" by Anne Michaels










We bathe our daughter,
a prayer for every part,
as if we were washing her
with song.
Fingers frail as blades of grass.
Her thousands of eggs,
already inside her.

1999

Sunday, September 25, 2005

Effects of the full moon, waning sun, or NHL strike?


It’s been a wild month at hospitals in Canada. At BC Women’s Hospital alone, there were 1000 expected births, with 500 being the norm. You could attribute the increase to the effects of the moon or the sun, or you could put it down to the NHL strike. Who knows! But on Wednesday of this week, all hospitals west of Saskatoon were on diversion - that means NO BEDS ANYWHERE!

There I was, early Wednesday evening, at a client’s house. She was getting deep into her labour, so I had called her doctor just to give her a “heads-up.” She told me something I didn't want to hear.
"Did you hear what’s going on at the hospital today?
They’re air-lifting women to Saskatoon! "
Yikes! I needed a game plan. We were facing minimal staffing at the hospital, no labour beds, and no postpartum beds. The most we could hope for was a bed to birth in if we arrived at full dilation. No epidural, no augmentation, no “on-demand” cesarean. Luckily, my client had been hoping for a natural labour. Heck - there was no other option today.

I silently called for wisdom and calm...

It’s interesting what the mind and body can do when faced with clearly defined boundaries. Quietly, I told my client what needed to happen. She needed to be relaxed and open, and to fully surrender to the rhythm of the labour for it to proceed swiftly and easily. We envisioned a smooth, graceful birth. Lying on her side, with my hand circling her lower back to induce a trance, my client became totally focused. She listened to her body and her baby, moving to the shower then the bath, then to standing. She swayed and rocked and stayed in the moment. Her labour progressed so quickly that it was less than two hours before I knew that this baby was coming soon.

I called the doctor once again.
"The dust is settling. We may have a room. I’m working on it."
It was a beautiful night. We drove through the busy streets to the hospital. As we walked into the hospital I saw another doula who said, incredulously...
"You got a room?!"
We got a room. The only room.

She pushed standing, then kneeling. That baby boy came so beautifully. So many joyful tears. Afterwards, I called my daughter.
"She had the birth I would wish for you."
Funny that when there are no options available, you must make do - and you do very well.

And we did very well again on Friday - another client, same scenario at the hospital - no beds, no meds - and another beautiful boy was born simply and gracefully. Wow - I love how women are able to rise to the occasion.

- Jacquie Munro, Vancouver Doula

Thursday, September 15, 2005

“Wow! If you had forceps last time, the next one will just FALL OUT!” (or, crazy predictions and expectations about second births)

I’ve attended so many second births recently, and I have 8 previous clients pregnant at the moment. So, I wanted to convey some of the joy and excitement of working with these second-time clients. I also wanted to talk about predictions and expectations surrounding second births.

So, today, for inspiration, I called a very special client whose little one is now about 18 months old. She picked up the phone and we both started grinning from ear to ear. “I’ve been thinking about you all this week!” she laughed. That’s the joy borne out of spending such an intense and sacred time together during her labour in 2004.

I love what I can do for a repeat client heading into the birth of her second child. If she has any lingering worries about the first birth, we can work on it together - because I was there! If it was a smooth and easy first birth, she may be worried about tempting fate: “It couldn’t possibly be THAT good TWICE!” We get to spend the whole nine months (and more) talking about what to expect. I get to remind her that she’s already a great mum, share stories about our amazing children (who cares that there’s a 20-year gap between our babies), have tea, chat on the phone, and plan for all eventualities. The doula role can expand from its intense focus on the “birth-day” to a broad look at “the big picture.” We can talk about mothering, families, and careers, while making it all relevant to the second birth.

Here are a few of the questions that usually come up during these chats:

“Ah, but how can I love a second child like I do my first?” This whispered question, like a deep secret, is always asked. The love for the firstborn is so profound that it can be scary entertaining the thought of loving another. But, just like the Grinch’s heart was able to expand, our hearts just miraculously DOUBLE in size when that second baby appears. Voila! It just works!

“And how will my firstborn be able to cope with the birth of a sibling?” Especially if there have been more than 3 years between children, the firstborn remembers how good life was before the new baby arrived. “You’re ALWAYS feeding the baby,” said my brother, as he walked past my mum in a huff. My own daughter got creative with a black indelible ink felt pen on the walls of our townhouse - up the stairs, around the corner - then signed it “saraH.” “No, it wasn’t me, mum. It was the other Sara down the street.” “Ah, but Sarah, her name doesn’t have an “H” at the end. Now, you obviously need huge swaths of paper to express yourself these days, don’t you?” And so you adapt, you cope, and the firstborn adjusts, too.

Remember, the firstborn is viewing all of this with the eyes of a small child, NOT the eyes of an adult. After a month, my daughter, then 3 1/2, said, “I did like it better before HE came.” I held onto that comment for years, worrying whether she still resented her little brother. Recently, I asked her about that comment. “Oh, mum, I was 3! That was a comment made in the moment. I would have loved him utterly the next day!” Hmmm.... Right.

“I’m confused. What’s with all these contractions?” This birth will follow a totally different rhythm from the first, and that may play with your mind, and your emotions. But remember, the body doesn’t know you have a brain that is constantly trying to figure out WHEN this labour is going to start. With a second baby, your body may be happily trying to get most of the work of labour done IN ADVANCE of the big day. Cool, eh? Your body can give you mild irregular contractions, or quite a bit of pelvic pressure, over the last few weeks. Your cervix may be quietly thinning, softening or dilating in advance. So, thank your body, let go of trying to figure out WHEN it will shift into active labour, and trust that the signs will be VERY CLEAR. Remember, you can page me whenever you like and we’ll figure it out together!

“I’m 4 cm. already. I’m sure the baby will come today.” During the last few weeks, you may be told “Your baby is really LOW,” “Your baby is really BIG,” or that “You’re 2, 3, 4, or 5 centimetres dilated ALREADY.” Please remember that these aren’t necessarily predictors of an imminent or speedy labour. They just mean that your body works beautifully. Who knows how long you’ve been 4 cm. dilated? You may have been this dilated for weeks. So, please think twice about your decision to have a vaginal assessment prior to labour with a second pregnancy. Think about what you will do with the information once you have it, and if it might negatively affect you emotionally. Then make your choice.

“So, are there any rules for a second birth?” Sure, everyone says that this birth will be about half the length of your first. But, I seem to spend about the same amount of time with both first AND second-timers. What’s that all about? The difference is in what we’re doing during those hours. There’s a lot more tea-making, chatting, walking, and playing with children during the second labour. There’s a lot of waiting for the labour to move from “easy-going early stuff” to the “wild and crazy finish.” Infinite patience and trust in the body are required during this birth. Because, when you least expect it, this labour will finally shift gears, and the baby will arrive with a splash.

There aren’t any rules for a second birth, but here are some helpful notes:
  • You may be piddling around in prelabour for days (Don’t worry, it’s all going to help in the long-run)
  • You can shift from prelabour to labour in a heartbeat (Watch for this shift in gears)
  • Once in true labour, it will probably be MUCH shorter than last time
  • Dilation is not a reliable indicator of when the baby will be born (You can go from 2-10 cm. in 15 minutes, or sit for weeks at 5 cm.)
  • If you say “The baby’s coming!” it’s coming within MINUTES, not HOURS
  • Pushing out a second baby is all about BREATHING it out, not “PUSHING”
  • Trust your body...it will surprise you!
- Jacquie Munro, Vancouver Doula

Wednesday, August 31, 2005

We're Home!

I've only been home from Scotland for less than 48 hours...and two new babies have already arrived. They were waiting for me to come home! One bonnie boy made a dramatic entrance...one leg born in Ladner, and the rest at BC Women's hospital. Spontaneous vaginal footling breech - less than 2 hours from start to finish, and no warning of the breech! What a night! Then a grand boy arrived at lunch-time today - almost 9 pounds of him. I think I can now change from Greenwich Mean Time to Pacific Time.

The trip to Scotland was the best yet! My son's band won the Juvenile World Pipe Band Championship title, Best Drum Corps, and Best Bass. Our Alex, as lead drummer, went up before 40,000 people to accept the trophy for best drum corps. What an amazing day!

And the views from the Dumyat...the sheep...the castles...the ferns and heather...
...they will be missed.

- Jacquie Munro, Vancouver Doula

Wednesday, August 03, 2005

Spring 2009 - "Mommy, What did you do in the industrial revolution?"

Mommy, what did you do in the industrial revolution? Meditations on the rising cesarean rate.

Plante, L.A. Mommy, What Did You Do in the Industrial Revolution? Meditations on the Rising Cesarean Rate. The International Journal of Feminist Approaches to Bioethics. Spring 2009;2(1):140-147.


Lauren A. Plante, MD, MPH, FACOG
Department of Obstetrics & Gynecology
Thomas Jefferson University
Philadelphia PA
Email: Lauren@LaurenPlante.net

The cesarean rate in the US has been rising for decades, and in 2006 hit an all-time high of 31% (Hamilton, 2007.) This record is likely to stand for only a brief time, that is, until figures are released for 2007. Can it really be that one-third of women are unable to birth without high-level technological support? And is there an endpoint in sight? “In the next decade or so the industrial revolution in obstetrics could make Cesarean delivery consistently safer than the birth process that evolution gave us.” (Gawande, 2006, 8) Against such an argument, who could hope to stand?

In a recent essay on the subject of childbirth, surgeon and author Atul Gawande muses on the Apgar score, obstetrical eponyms, and the rising cesarean rate. (Gawande, 2006) Although he lauds the success—often unheralded-- of obstetrics in saving mothers’ and infants’ lives, I hear within the paean a threnody for the vanishing art. Skilled obstetricians like those legends of the past, whose names lived on in the maneuvers they devised to usher babies into the world, are vanishing from current practice: goodbye, Lovset; hit the road, Rubin; Mauriceau, it’s been swell, but we’re through.

Gawande makes a case for the standardization of obstetrics. “You seek reliability. You begin to wonder whether forty-two thousand obstetricians…could really master all these techniques…obstetricians decided that they needed a simpler, more predictable way to intervene when a laboring mother ran into trouble. They found it in the Cesarean section.” (7) He suggests that techniques for effecting vaginal delivery—maneuvers to reduce a shoulder dystocia, deliver a breech baby, assist delivery with forceps—are so subject to variations in skill that they cannot be standardized for reliably good outcomes, while the cesarean operation is commonplace and consistent. It is, if you will, the least common denominator: every obstetrician knows how to perform one. While this is a fascinating perspective on the changing of obstetrical practice, for those of us who actually work on a busy obstetrical unit industrialized childbirth conjures up images of the factory floor.

The drive toward fewer delivery options appears at first glance to be supported by upper-middle-class women, who have the least number of social and economic obstacles to autonomy. In fact, cynical staff at hospitals delivering large numbers of well-insured upper-middle- class women often refer to their institutions as baby factories: these are the places in which cesarean rates are highest. It is, after all, a paradox: women with higher incomes, higher levels of education, and commercial insurance have higher rates of cesarean delivery. If cesarean is a response to any perceived risk, why would women at statistically lower risk of a poor outcome have higher cesarean delivery rates? New Jersey has the highest cesarean rate among states, (Denk 2006) but no lower levels of maternal or perinatal mortality. (MacDorman 2007, CDC 1999) What it does have, however, is the highest median household income. (Census Bureau 2007)

Does this paradox reflect a differential understanding of risk? I have seen, over years of practice in maternal-fetal medicine, an odd and somewhat unsettling pride among women who announce that they have a “high-risk pregnancy.” Although the inherent literal meaning of the term high-risk pregnancy is one that entails a greater risk of a poor outcome (for mother or baby,) the subtext seems to be that high risk equals high value. In some cases it is difficult to persuade a low-risk woman to continue her care with a general OBGYN practice instead. “But I’m high-risk,” she says. Does she really mean, “I’m high-status,” or “My baby is high-value,” specifically, more precious than someone else’s? Is it a statement of importance? Does it mean that she is special? Or is it a Disneyfication of a primal human endeavor, longing for the synthetic and dramatized experience in preference to the authentic? These questions are raised, but cannot possibly be answered, in this commentary.

Women who want to be high-risk (read: special) in their designation are nonetheless hugely risk-averse when it comes to the real thing. Obstetricians have tapped into that fear in daily practice. Vaginal birth after cesarean (VBAC), for example, is associated with a very low although measurable risk of uterine rupture. Presented with the figures and asked to sign a consent for VBAC which spells out that risk, most women now decline: the VBAC rate in 2005 was under 8%. (Martin, 2006) Whether this is driven by reluctance of doctors to offer or women to undergo VBAC is impossible to ascertain, but it is clear that fear is contagious. And the indications for the initial cesarean—without which the question of VBAC would never be raised—have broadened considerably: breeches, twins, large babies, small babies, slow labor, even no labor. We now see the phenomenon of perfectly healthy, low-risk pregnant women requesting cesarean delivery upfront, in an attempt to eliminate all potential labor-associated risk for the infant. Even in the absence of any medical or obstetric indication for abdominal delivery, many women now seem eager to go under the knife. Somehow a perspective is emerging that cesarean is the best bet for delivery.

National cesarean rates do correlate—inversely—with both neonatal mortality and maternal mortality rates at the extreme low end of the spectrum. For developing or low-income countries, where access to safe maternity care is an issue, a rise in national CS rates from 0% to 8-10% is accompanied by a drop in stillbirths, neonatal deaths, and maternal deaths. (Goldenberg 2007, McClure 2007.) But across the developed world, or across medium- and high-income countries, there is no additional benefit of further increase in cesarean rate (Althabe 2006.): Slovenia, with a 12% cesarean rate, has the same maternal mortality ratio as the US. Nordic maternal mortality ratios are only a fraction of the American, at a 50% lower cesarean rate. Neonatal mortality does not change in high-income countries across a range of CS rates from 10-40%. (Althabe) Infant mortality rates as low as 4 per 1000 are achieved at CS rates of 15% in a number of countries, contrasting favorably with the US infant mortality rate of 7 per 1000: the American system results in infant mortality nearly twice as high achieved at the cost of twice as many cesareans. It is hard to make the argument on a population basis that abdominal delivery is safer for mothers or babies, at least after a minimal necessary rate is achieved.

Nonetheless, seduced by the promise of pain-free, risk-free childbirth, women and their doctors are driving the cesarean rate ever higher. Rates approaching—or exceeding-- fifty percent are now seen in some hospitals (New Jersey Star-Ledger.) This is the normalization of deviance. This is the new normal.

It would be unfortunate enough if the push toward CS were limited to a few upper-middle-class women (“too posh to push.”) But, judging from the South American experience, everyone wants the lifestyle of the rich and famous. Cesarean rates as high as 80% among well-off women in the private sector in Brazil (Kilsztajn 2007) appear to have created prevalent expectations, either among physicians or among other groups of women, that cesarean is the preferred option. (Potter 2008; Behague 2002; Angeja 2006) In at least some cases, poor women have been known to put away their own funds to ensure they will be delivered abdominally rather than vaginally. This would suggest they are concerned about inequitable or unfair treatment unless they deliver by cesarean. In the US, we have heard arguments that women are entitled to autonomy in making their birth choices, and that therefore it is ethical to perform cesarean for no reason other than maternal request. Curiously, this vaunted autonomy stops at the door of the labor room. Women are implicitly allowed, or encouraged, to make only those choices which increase the power of the physician and which decrease their own.

Let us enumerate what a full spectrum of childbirth choices entails. Women can give birth at home unaided; at home with family or with trained assistance; in a birth center, either freestanding or hospital-based; in the hospital delivery room with trained assistance; or in the operating room where they are acted upon. But of all these choices, extending across the entire range of reliance upon the medical profession (from none to total), exercising the options at the end of the spectrum where the physician has the least sway will get women the least support. The American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists calumniates not only women who want a home birth but anyone who advocates leaving that option open. (American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, 2008.) Once in the hospital, women who might like to exercise their right to self-determination by choosing vaginal birth after cesarean, or vaginal breech delivery, will have a hard time of it. (Leeman and Plante, 2006) Is it not the opposite of autonomy to support only those choices which increase the woman’s reliance upon the physician?

Industrial obstetrics strips the locus of power definitively away from women. The history of childbirth in America reflects a persistent trend of increased control by physicians and increased medicalization. Childbirth moves, first, out of the home, and now out of the vagina. Stipulate that antibiotics and blood banks are good and necessary things, and that emergencies may, in fact, develop: still, the majority of births will be normal. Or they would be, without interference. The species that cannot birth its young becomes extinct. But fear has pushed nearly all American childbirth into the hospital, a campaign which continues even now that that battle looks to have been won. (American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, 2008) Still, despite the implied promise of safety if all the rules are followed—ID bracelets, intravenous lines, electronic fetal monitoring---labor may follow an unpredictable path. The definition of “normal” becomes ever narrower, and toleration of deviance ever lower. The final stage of this philosophy takes the process of birth away from the woman entirely and turns it into a surgical procedure performed by the doctor. Childbirth becomes a manufactured experience, shorn of any real risk or real power, one in which the woman is so far alienated from the capabilities of her body that she is only a package on an operating table for a professional to open.

We’ve seen industrial revolutions before. The classic example gave us cheap toys and manufactured goods. At first the consumer focuses on the price point and on the sheer reproducibility: every Thomas and Friends wooden railway toy is just like every other. When you reduce variation, you get “normal,” by anyone’s definition. The very notion of quality control is rooted in the factory. Economies of scale and industrial production give consumers cheaper product than the handcrafted item, so that just about anyone can afford to buy toys from China. (Unfortunately, cost is an issue for manufacturers too: lead paint is cheaper than the alternatives, so nearly 2 million of those Thomas and Friends wooden trains were recalled for safety concerns last year. Sometimes safety is trumped by other considerations when industry rules.) While industrialization reduces cost and reduces variation, it is not an unqualified good. Should we be so quick to cheer the industrialization of childbirth? (Gawande, 2006)

The industrialization of food production is, perhaps, a harbinger of the industrialization of childbirth. Food production was once local, varied and small-scale, but farms have been taken over by huge conglomerates, and monoculture of a small number of genetically uniform crops has replaced variety. The disappearance of cultivars—that is, the loss of deviants—means that random natural events could wipe out large swaths of the food supply. To draw an even more pointed parallel, meat in America is cheap and widely available because of industrialized animal production. These animals lead narrowly confined lives from conception to death. Reliance on a small number of breeds, confined animal feeding operations, and the production line essentially turn animals into factory products. Industrial animal production has exacted a price in ways that until recently were invisible to the average consumer: the pollution of air and groundwater, the increasing potential for foodborne illness, the escalation of antibiotic resistance which begins in industrial herds but moves into human populations, even the quality of those animals’ lives. Clearly, industrialization has a downside, although we may not notice the drawbacks until all competing models have vanished. While some would object to drawing an analogy between industrial food production and industrial childbirth, I submit that in both cases we see a conversion of a living creature to a commodity, with an emphasis on the end product and a marked disinterest in the natural process over time. Women can be processed through the childbirth machine and handed a baby at the other end, stripping them of their central role at the heart of things, and turning them instead into objects that someone else operates upon.

The paradox is this: women wish to be treated as individuals, and assert for themselves a wish to exert control, yet in the commodification and industrialization of childbirth they are so much more likely to be treated as units of production. I know of one large community hospital revamping their labor floor and planning for a 50% cesarean delivery rate: and just as we learned in the 1989 movie, Field of Dreams, if you build it, they will come. The staffing and scheduling patterns for a 50% cesarean rate, as well as administration plans for hospital length of stay, can’t be turned on a dime. Hospital administrations like predictability, in patient patterns, patient care pathways, and everything else. If we normalize this industrialized approach to childbirth, we are likely to be stuck in it for a very long time indeed—and we can’t look to the medical profession to correct it.

But maybe, just maybe, there’s a backlash coming. An entire generation of American women fed their infants artificial formula because they were told it was modern, convenient, and better for their babies. Decades of medical progress later, two-thirds of mothers at least attempt breastfeeding. (Wright 2001) The women’s movement has challenged the hegemony of the medical profession in the past. (Kaiser and Kaiser, 1974)

As a reaction to industrial agriculture and food marketing, the Slow Food and locavore movements have recently been born. If de-escalation of our food production practices is healthier or more humane, why is intensification of our child production practices better than sustainable childbirth? I’m waiting for the birth of the revolution, or at least, the revolution of birth. Will women who are interested in Slow Food or cage-free eggs find their way to a Slow Childbirth movement? Imagine: educated upper-middle-class women who buy songbird-certified organic coffee and worry about their carbon footprint, just saying no to the quick-fix cesarean culture. If they’re not part of the problem, maybe they can be part of the solution. But the impetus must come from women themselves. Do we really believe that industrial obstetrics is the best model for ourselves and our children? We must clearly understand that real autonomy does not mean cesarean on request, but instead a spectrum of birth options that honor women’s authentic choices. Real autonomy also means, to borrow a sentiment from Gandhi, that women should bring forth the change they wish to see in the world.

References

Althabe F, Sosa C, Belizan JM, Gibbons L, Jacquerioz F, Bergel E. 2006. Cesarean section rates and maternal and neonatal mortality in low-, medium-, and high-income countries: an ecological study. Birth 33 (4): 270-7.

American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists. 2008. ACOG Statement on Home Births. News release, 2/6/08. Online at http://www.acog.org/from_home/publications/press_releases/nr02-06-08-2.cfm. Accessed 3/20/08

Angeja ACE, Washington AE, Vargas JE, Gomez R, Rojas I, Caughey AB. 2006. Chilean women’s preferences regarding mode of delivery: which do they prefer and why? British Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology 113 (11): 1253-8.

Behague DP, Victora CG, Barros FC. 2002. Consumer demand for caesarean sections in Brazil: informed decision making, patient choice, or social inequality? A population based birth cohort study linking ethnographic and epidemiological methods. British Medical Journal 324 (7343): 942-7.

Centers for Disease Control. State-specific maternal mortality among black and white women—United States, 1987-1996. Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report 1999; 48: 492-6

Denk CE, Kruse LK, Jain NJ. 2006. Surveillance of cesarean section deliveries, New Jersey 1999-2004. Topics in Health Statistics October 2005 (revised January 2006.) New Jersey Department of Health and Senior Services, Center for Health Statistics, Trenton NJ.

Gawande A. 2006. The score: how childbirth went industrial. New Yorker, October 9, 2006: 1-9, http://www.newyorker.com/archive/2006/10/09/061009fa_fact?currentPage=1, Accessed 3/21/08.

Gandhi, M. 2002. As quoted in "Arun Gandhi Shares the Mahatma's Message" by Michel W. Potts, in India - West [San Leandro, California] Vol. XXVII, No. 13 (1 February 2002): p. A34.

Goldenberg RL, McClure EM, Bann CM. 2007. The relationship of intrapartum and antepartum stillbirth rates to measures of obstetric care in developed and developing countries. Acta Obstetricia et Gynecologica 2007; 86 (11): 1303-9.

Hamilton BE, Martin JA, Ventura SJ. 2006. Births: preliminary data for 2006. National Vital Statistics Reports. 56 (7). http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/nvsr/nvsr56/nvsr56_07.pdf. Accessed 3/21/08.

Kaiser BL, Kaiser IH. 1974. The challenge of the women’s movement to American gynecology. American Journal of Obstetrics & Gynecology. 120 (5): 652-65.

Kilsztajn S, do Carmo MSN, Machado LC, Lopes ES, Lima LZ. 2007. Caesarean sections and maternal mortality in Sao Paulo. Eur J Obstet Gynecol Reprod Biol . 132 (1): 64-9.

Leeman LM, Plante LA. 2006. Patient-choice vaginal delivery? Annals of Family Medicine. 4(3): 265-8.

MacDorman MF, Hoyert DL, Martin JA, Munson ML, Hamilton BE. 2007. Fetal and perinatal mortality, United States, 2003. National Vital Statistics Reports 55 (6). February 21, 2007.

Martin JA, Hamilton BE, Sutton PD, Ventura SJ, Menacker F, Kirmeyer S, Munson ML. 2007. Births: final data for 2005. Nat Vital Statistics Reports 56 (6). Online at http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/nvsr/nvsr56/nvsr56_06.pdf. Accessed 3/28/08

McClure EM, Goldenberg RL, Bann CM. 2007. Maternal mortality, stillbirth and measures of obstetric care in developing and developed countries. International Journal of Gynecology and Obstetrics 96 (2): 139-46.

New Jersey Star-Ledger. 2006. Giving birth in New Jersey. http://www.starledger.com/str/indexpage/environment/default.asp Accessed 3/29/08.

Potter JE, Hopkins K, Faundes A. Perpetuo I. 2008. Women’s autonomy and scheduled cesarean sections in Brazil: a cautionary tale. Birth 35 (1): 33-40.

United States Census Bureau, 2006. Two-year-average median household income by state: 2003-2005. http://www.census.gov/hhes/www/incomeincome06/statemhi2.html. Accessed 3/21/08.

Wright AL. 2001. The rise of breastfeeding in the United States. Pediatric Clinics of North America 48(1): 1-12.

Friday, July 29, 2005

Bountiful Beautiful Blissful


It's August, so I am leaving for a month in Scotland without my pager...what an amazing concept. Being on call 24/7 can take its toll. Think of those lucky ones who are due in September. They will receive a fully rejuvenated me! And I do hope I don't come home to find my backup was busy with everyone! Fingers crossed!

While I'm away, I hope each of you takes some time to browse the shelves at Banyen Books. My favorite book of 2005 is "Bountiful, Beautiful, Blissful", by Gurmukh. Don't be scared off by thinking it may be too flakey - it's not, and incorporates many of the words and concepts that I use when working with pregnant and labouring women (I even sang "Row, row, row your boat" to myself during my second labour in 1987). When I read Gurmukh's book I feel as if she and I know each other intimately, and have been using each other's phrases for years. So, have a good read!

- Jacquie Munro, Vancouver Doula

Tuesday, July 19, 2005

Jacquie Munro - Vancouver Doula

Doula - n. a Greek word referring to an experienced woman who helps other women. The word has now come to mean a woman experienced in childbirth who provides continuous physical, emotional, and information support to the mother and her family before, during, and after childbirth.

I help you to realize that you have the abilities, wisdom and courage to give birth. Birth is something that you know on a basic level. I just help you to access that knowledge.

My care includes:
  • 2 prenatal visits for teaching and planning
  • pre/post-natal telephone consultations
  • physical and emotional support during labour and birth at your home and/or hospital
  • written birth notes
  • 1 postpartum home or hospital visit (and unlimited postpartum phone calls!)

The Research
When a doula is present, it results in:
  • a 25% reduction in the length of labour
  • a greater than 50% drop in cesarean sections
  • a 60% drop in the mother's need for epidurals
  • a 30% reduction in the mother's need for other pain medications
  • a 40% reduction in the need for oxytocin and forceps
  • a higher incidence of breastfeeding success

Some investigators theorize that stress hormones cause the labour of many mothers to slow down, making complications more likely and the labour experience more stressful. By reducing the woman's (and her partner's) fear through calm reassuring words, touch, and relaxation techniques, the doula helps to moderate these reactions, ultimately lessening the need for medical interventions and shortening the labour.

How can I help?
As your doula, I am the person who helps you to understand the rhythm of labour and birth, who comes to your house when your labour is beginning to intensify, who helps you to find comfort, and reduces your fears. I work with you and your partner, teaching you both to understand the wisdom and the logic of the body, so you can recognize and accept the changes in labour. I encourage you to move, to take showers, to get into just the right position for your baby. I can help with relaxation and massage, taking turns with your partner, so that he or she never becomes too tired. Whether the labour is straight-forward, or you encounter the unexpected, you should both feel empowered by your ability to make informed choices. The effects of a positive birth experience can immeasurably increase your self-esteem, and strengthen your relationship with your partner and baby.

To the Dads: I am your resource person during the birth. I can explain what is happening, what you can do to help, how you can effectively work with your other caregivers. One dad described me as a choreographer. You both do the dancing, I just help you to look good! Or you could see me as the best waiter you've ever had, always knowing intuitively what you want next, or when you both need privacy!

During your Pregnancy: I will meet with you both to discuss your hopes, dreams, and concerns. We will talk about your own best ways of coping with pain and fatigue and how you and your partner foresee working together, and with me. We will discuss roles, expectations, comfort measures, and the rhythm of labour. We will build on the information you received in your prenatal or yoga classes.

You can phone or email me at any time with your questions, or just to chat. I suggest that you call before or after each prenatal visit with your caregiver. Our contact will usually increase as your due date approaches. During the on-call period (two weeks prior to and after your due date), I am generally available 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. I will give you as much advance notice of times when I may be unavailable due to illness, birth conflicts or planned vacations. To cover those times, I call on other experienced doulas for back-up. You do have a choice about whether you use the back-up, or which doula you'd like.

I strongly encourage you to develop and maintain a trusting relationship with your physician or midwife. Discuss with your caregiver what you expect from her, and what you expect from me, your doula. This goes a long way toward creating a positive birth environment. I am happy to meet with your caregiver in person or over the phone at your request.

When you are in labour: I prefer that you call me as soon as you think you might be in labour. I can reassure you, answer your questions, and make suggestions over the phone. Together we will decide if I should come right away or wait for further changes. I usually need one hour to reach you. Depending on your labour, we may meet at your home or at the hospital. No matter what, we will remain in touch with your caregiver or hospital during early labour, for safety. Except for extraordinary circumstances, I (or my back-up) will remain with you throughout the labour and birth.

After the birth: I usually remain with you for one or two hours after the birth, until you are comfortable and your family is ready for quiet time together. I can also help with initial breastfeeding if you wish. I am available for phone consultations during the postpartum period to answer questions about the birth or your baby. I will visit you at home or hospital within the first 8 weeks to see how you are doing, to review the birth, and to give you the birth notes. If you think you might need help in the weeks after the birth, I can make a referral to a postpartum doula.

As a doula, I do not:
  • Perform clinical tasks such as blood pressure readings, fetal heart checks, and vaginal exams. Your physician, midwife, or nurse will provide that service.
  • Make decisions for you. However, I will help you get the information necessary to make informed decisions, and be your advocate.

Fees: My rates are available upon request. There is an initial non-refundable booking/prenatal visit fee due when you select me as your doula, plus a birth fee which is payable within two weeks of the birth.

Please Note: I will make every effort to be at your birth. If I am unable to attend your birth or provide back-up due to circumstances beyond our control (e.g. emergency cesarean, unforseen illness, etc), you will not be charged the birth fee. However, I will retain the booking/prenatal visit fee, which covers the cost of prenatal visit(s), phone calls, and handouts.

I look forward to working with you!

- Jacquie Munro
vancouverdoula@gmail.com


Every birth is an adventure.

No matter how many times a woman has given birth, she is setting out on a new experience.

I hope to support you during this life changing time, and help you to create a positive memory of your pregnancy, birth and postpartum experience.

Saturday, July 16, 2005

This is what it's all about

"Mi muchacha salvaje" My wild girl

Birth is something you know. Can you imagine arriving at the age of 30, and having your body throwing you an entirely new experience - something without a reference point? It’s just not that nasty.

Birthing is a lot like lovemaking...and Buddhist teachings, for that matter. It involves surrender, letting go, release, acceptance, and total trust. It also involves passion and power, which, for some, can be overwhelming. For others, it can be a process of awakening, change and growth.

Yes, birth is like lovemaking - and the majority of people would think there was a world of difference between birthing sounds and lovemaking sounds. But there isn’t - they are both an expression of intense creative power. The only problem is that I’m so used to birthing sounds that I only categorize groans and moans as birthing sounds. This can get me into trouble. Oh, dear!

So, there I was - on a walk with my husband last summer. The heat was so thick that it hummed. All doors and windows were open to the still air. Walking past a house, I heard the sounds of a moaning, panting woman, “Oh, GOD! Oh, GOD!”

“Bob...I’ve got to go help her!”

“Sweetie, no - She needs no help.” Why does he have that smile?

“No, Bob, you don't understand. She sounds like she’s about 5-6 centimetres. Maybe they’re worried they won’t get to the hospital in time!” I was so anxious, I was ready to knock on the door.

“No, dear, she’s fine - let’s keep walking.”

Then silence in the heat...

OH, MY!

Sorry...

She wasn’t in labour.

Thanks to my husband for being so wonderfully understanding and accepting of my focus on birth (sigh!).

Birthing and lovemaking are psychosexual processes. Most women aren't fearful of lovemaking, though the experience can be overwhelming both physically and emotionally. There's a loss of self, a letting-go, a transformation of the perception of space and time, and the knife-edge of pleasure and pain. The sounds we make are deep and open. However, if consent is not given the experience leads to pain, anger and emotional damage. For birth to be as open as consentual lovemaking, there needs to be consent given by the woman to her body. She needs to consent and surrender to this powerful psychosexual process. She needs to trust her body.

Birthing is truly something that we are prepared for on a cellular level. But our twenty-first century brains fight for supremacy over the reptile brain within us. We try to label and time and impose a structure on this force which is all about fluidity and stillness of mind. Yes, there will be a struggle within the mind and body, but eventually there needs to be acceptance and a surrendering to the body’s knowledge and power. The length of that struggle is what determines how easily we birth.

Now, of course, this is assuming that all is well physically, and the baby hasn’t decided that today he is going to try to come feet first, or elbows above the head, or sucking both thumbs. Yes, there’s the wild card baby at play. It’s not just about the mother. We have to trust that the baby is an active player here, pressing and wiggling the head against the mother’s muscles...pushing his feet against the top of the uterus. And we must trust that the baby will wave a big red flag if there’s trouble. Trust, acceptance and surrender are involved here. The baby is wise.

So, how to prepare for this wild ride? Live in the moment, look into your love’s eyes, experience passion together, trust each other, walk on the beach together, make noise, dance, read, sleep, trust your body, laugh, let your mind be still. And know that you will come out the other side a family.

- Jacquie Munro, Vancouver Doula

Tuesday, June 28, 2005

...the way some collect spoons













After the Birth

in her mind
she goes over and over the details,
how, close to the end,
she could no longer stand
the sound of her husband's breathing,
the pain
and the need to keep pushing
long after the baby was out
and the midwife gone

months later,
she still wants her husband
in bed late at night
to tell her once again what happened
but he is tired of broken sleep
and the crying babe
so she turns to other women
and collects birthing stories
the way some collect spoons

I'm home from a birth that spanned the night. Driving through the dark, I saw the husband turn left on yellow, wheels spinning ahead of me. She walked through the shushing doors and slowly lowered her body to the floor. - Are you feeling pressure? She nods. Husband with tears in eyes. Woman low moaning, rocking , swaying, hand tracing circles in the air. Ready to push so soon. In her own room now, windows open to the dark night. Birds singing at 2am. Such power. Then blocked by the power. Moving sitting, kneeling, no use, can't push, squatting, no good, standing, pushing in the chest. I shake her hips and she surrenders to the deep power and slides the baby down, body opening, and out into her arms. Dad streaming tears. Mum laughing laughing laughing... "Sophia!"

- Jacquie Munro, Vancouver Doula

Thursday, June 23, 2005

So, what’s the best birth book to read?




In 1982, I was obsessed with everything to do with babies. I ducked into every book store for months before I got pregnant. You’d find me sitting on the floor by the Pregnancy and Childbirth section, surrounded by books. These weren’t “Earth Mother” books. I started with the encyclopedic books, looking for the ones authored by doctors with the most letters behind their names... FRCP, etc. You know, the books which scare you half to death with descriptions of all possible things which can go wrong. Then, I went to the university medical bookstore to look at obstetric textbooks. I even studied an obscure Swiss method of breathing for labour, which I photocopied from the main library. This method left me exhausted, out of breath, and very, very confused. It didn’t help when my husband and I went to prenatal classes and pretty much “failed” breathing. And when the nurses at the hospital asked us what our “birth plan” was, we just said “to have it go well”, and then I asked if I could blow-dry my hair before the obstetrician started my induction. Yikes! Over-prepared with book knowledge....under-prepared with inner knowledge.

Then, when I was pregnant for the second time, I found that reading C.S. Lewis’ “The Lion, The Witch, and the Wardrobe” to my daughter brought so much more inner peace and contentment. I was working with midwives this time, and my visits were filled with laughter, and great book recommendations. I read Elizabeth Noble’s “Childbirth with Insight” which teaches you to trust your inner wisdom, Ina Mae Gaskin’s “Spiritual Midwifery”, which, once you get past the now-quaint 60’s language, is a deeply truthful account of birth, and anything by Sheila Kitzinger. My midwives reminded me that I didn’t need books to teach me how to give birth. They said I needed to trust my body, and to visualize a positive outcome. So, this time, you’d find me sitting with my daughter on the floor of the Children’s section in the bookstore. I bought books with beautiful illustrations, mystical children’s books, books which fed our souls. And when I went into labour, I trusted my body, danced with my husband, and experienced childbirth with joy.

After what seems a lifetime as a doula, I spend more time discussing recent book group titles with my clients, than recommending so-called “birth books”. Most clients say that they’ve not read any birth book which truly speaks to them and their experience. So, I recommend books which will help them through their journey. One woman, who was an engineer, had to leave work because of high blood pressure, and wanted to know how to slow down and face the looming prospect of 5 weeks on bed-rest. I asked her husband to pick up the first of the “Outlander” series by Diana Gabaldon, a good historical “bodice-ripper”. After a week, she called to say she had finally found a book which could keep her glued to her seat...and “what’s the next title in the series!” By the time she went into labour, she had slowed down, and, in the process, learned so much about herself.

When I walk into clients houses, the first thing I look at are their bookshelves. I can tell so much about each couple by seeing what books are prominently displayed. Ah, she must have been an English major... Ah, he’s an engineer interested in science fiction. And there, on her bedside table, is a copy of Harry Potter. One couple were concerned about their baby being born “different”. Should I mention “The Chrysalids” by John Wyndham, a science-fiction novel which explores the nature of “difference”?

Should I recommend “The Giver” by Lois Lowry, to people who are looking for the “perfect pain-free birth”? In this children’s book, “Jonas’s world is perfect. Everything is under control. There is no war or fear or pain.” Once I broke free of the confines of “birth books”, I was free to help women prepare for birth in a way which honours them as individuals, which works with them in a much more holistic way.

Birth rips off all blinkers, exposes us for who we really are, forces us to face others without masks. We cannot “prepare” for this encounter with ourselves. We can only explore our inner selves as much as possible before the labour comes, and trust that birth is something we know on a basic level. I truly believe that reading for pleasure helps us to achieve a trance-like state, and, allows us to see ourselves mirrored within the pages of the book.

See what books speak to you...

- Jacquie Munro, Vancouver Doula

We are the Doorways of Life

“‘Breathing for a hollow organ’ works well in labour. Breathe in...breathe out. Allow there to be space after the out breath, a time for nothingness, for the hollow organ to be still. Then wait for the body to take in the next breath. Listen to the sound of the breath as it goes in and out...circular, whole.”

This is the centre of labour. The breath is a reminder that there is continuity in all things. There is safety and surety in the breath which goes on and on throughout the wild storm of labour. Even when the labour reaches the point at which it can be called “white lightning”, the breath is constant as ever. And in the quiet times, between contractions, the breath is soft and open.

“Breathe in strength, breathe away the fear. Listen to the sound of the breath...in and out. Each breath takes you closer to the end of a contraction. Then comes a deep breath, down to the ground, and a long slow sigh...which brings quiet and rest.”

Around the central core of the breath is the movement of the body. The body rocks and sways in rhythm with the breath. Kneeling and squatting, leaning and dancing...the body moves as it wants. At times it wants stillness and rest. At times it wants to match the intensity of the power within. The hands trace circular patterns in the air. The toes point, as the feet trace the patterns of a dancer.

“Allow your breath to take you deeper and deeper inside yourself. Allow your breath to make music. Your sounds will sing to the baby. Your body will rock the baby. You are safe, the baby is safe.”

Deep into the labour, the trance comes. Space and time alter. The mind accepts the power of the event, and the breath continues at the centre. One breath, one breath, one breath. Live in the moment. The body opens. In the spaces between contractions there is sleep and dreams. The breath takes form and becomes a voice, a sound, a song. Round and open, the “ohhhh” of labour begins.

“Picture the baby, chin on chest, deep down, wriggling to find the perfect fit in the cradle of your pelvis. Feet press against the top of your womb, helping the baby dive down, down towards the light.”

The “ohhh” sounds open the throat, open the vagina. The labour now has a rhythm, a form, which is known and safe. The power gathers and intensifies. Yet, around the woman, there are hands to hold her, hands to stroke her, echoing the rhythms of her body. The room is dark, the voices are calm and quiet. She knows she is safe. She lives in the moment. She lives with her breath. Time and space mean nothing. Her circle of awareness has become smaller and smaller. Only the eyes that look into hers matter. Only the voices that hear her whispers matter.

“Soon, you will feel a deep pressure at the peak of the contraction. That is safe. You’ll want to fight against the urge, or to push with it...but you will breathe deeper, more open. Listen to the sound of your breath. Let the baby press down, let the body change from opening to giving birth. Your mind will rebel, but your body will know what to do. Trust your body. You are strong. You are safe, your baby is safe.”

And the moment comes when the power is confusing. The rhythm is dashed and ragged. The eyes are wide...

“My baby is coming!”

The power shifts, the trance is gone. The ‘feminine’ opening part of labour has ended, and the ‘masculine’ pushing part of labour begins. The hands pull, the body curls, and the baby presses deeper. The feet need the firm ground to press on...bare feet on hard ground. A deep squat, eyes closed, hard work...then rest. A growl escapes the throat. Everything in life is present at this moment. Pain, pleasure, joy, acceptance, struggle, love, fear, patience, anger, power... At this moment the door between life and death is wide open. The woman as she knew herself is gone, but in giving birth to a baby, she gives birth to a new woman. In giving birth, both a mother and a baby are born. And she is safe, and her baby is safe.

“And it comes back to the breath, with joy. The baby’s breath comes, the soul is strong in the body.”

- Jacquie Munro, Vancouver Doula

Monday, June 20, 2005

Mindful Words

Picture a birthing room. A woman is leaning over beside a bed, and the voices around her are saying...
“You look so tired!”
“That baby isn’t very happy.”
”It can’t possibly be time for you to push yet.”

She drops her head, and cries...

The language that we use in the birthing room touches a woman deeply. When in active labour, a woman is so open to suggestion that any negative word can sap her energy and make her want to give up completely. Her negative emotions can then slow down the labour, or cause complications that would never have happened if those words had never been spoken.

Picture that same birthing room. The woman is leaning over the bed, and the voices around her are saying...
“You’re so powerful...I know it must be hard, but you can do this!”
“Your baby’s head must be coming down for the heart rate to drop then recover so quickly. That’s a good sign!”
“Trust your body...it will tell you when it’s time to push.”

The woman lifts up her head, and smiles...

Smiles in a birthing room? You must be joking! Well, there can be smiles and laughter, and incredible joy. But you don’t hear about that side of birth. People want to tell stories of blood and pain, exhaustion and tears, doctors’ golf games, needles, and drugs.
No one dares mention that there can be joy during labour. You might laugh at them!

Studies have shown that women never forget their birth experiences. They often recount stories of their births using the exact words spoken by caregivers. One eighty year old women recalls the head matron standing in the doorway with her Great Dane, saying, “You can’t possibly be ready to give birth. Stay in bed. I’m far too busy. The dog will stand guard.” Another woman questioned her obstetrician about the need for a cesarean, so he asked, “Do you want to have your child taken to school in a Funny Bus?” When I found out I was pregnant with my second child, and questioned the need for a vacuum-assisted delivery at my first birth, my physician said, “Well, what did you want...a dead baby?” The start of my path towards empowerment came with that doctor’s question. I stood up, left the room, and slammed the door. I hired midwives for my second birth, wrote a letter of complaint to the doctor, and worked to surround myself with positive words. The language that people use can hurt us, but it can also heal us.

Most of the language used in hospital birthing rooms is medical, masculine, and certainly not positive. “Incompetent cervix”, “elderly primip”, and “trial of labour” are a few phrases which make women feel less than capable. Women don’t “give birth”, they are “delivered by the doctor”. In the hospital setting, women find themselves using prison-terms to describe their stay: “I was released” or “They let me out”. Falling into the role of patient, the labouring woman starts to ask permission to go to the bathroom, to move, to make noise, undermining her own body’s natural inclinations. When I was in labour with my daughter, I automatically got into the hands and knees position. My body knew that this was the best position to help my daughter turn and fit well into the cradle of my pelvis. I started to rock and sway and hum. I was coping well. Then a new nurse walked into the room and said, “Well, that’s a weird position to get into!”, and shook her head. Being vulnerable and open to suggestion, I turned over, sat down, and lost my ability to listen to my body. The body speaks to us in labour. If everyone else was quiet, maybe we could hear the body better, and perhaps there would be less medical intervention.

Perhaps the most wonderful example of this came at a birth I attended many years ago. The labouring woman was deaf. She didn’t use sign language, and would generally read lips. However, during her labour, she closed her eyes, finding comfort in an internal focus. She said she loved to hear her body talking to her in the labour. Her husband and I communicated with her by using our hands - to touch, to stroke, to hold, to hug. She laboured beautifully, accepting the wisdom of her body, and gaining strength through the calmness of our hands. Ah, but the nurse kept trying to tell the woman what to do from behind - always forgetting that her words would go unheard.

During labour, a woman goes deep into herself. One father described this basic instinctual process, “Getting in touch with her reptile brain”. As support people, we should do whatever we can to nurture that process, but quietly, and one at a time. The “reptile brain” can’t deal with many voices, many demands. Quiet, confident messages whispered into her ear can really help. “You are strong”, “You are safe”, “Your baby is strong”, “You can do this”. Encouragement from many voices may seem helpful to the supporters, but to the labouring woman it can seem demanding. It can reinforce the feelings of self-doubt - “Am I doing okay?” “They’re all calling to me because they know something I don’t know”. Quiet presence is more strengthening. One woman who had her baby last week, said that it became very confusing at the end, because a number of new people entered the room and started telling her what to do. Then she felt my hand reach for hers and heard my voice, quiet and calm, in her ear, saying, “Just block out the voices and breathe out your baby. Open your eyes and see your baby.” So, instead of being confused, she said she gained clarity, and time stood still. She opened her eyes, and breathed her baby out - watching the whole thing. She was also so fully present that later described being able to feel the baby’s head, shoulders, arms, hand, and hips, as they came through her and out into the world. What joy!

By being mindful and gentle with our words, we can help women give birth with joy. This doesn’t mean that there won’t be a struggle, or pain, or moments when she will doubt her ability to continue. This just means that we won’t be making her journey more difficult by using words which add to her struggle. Rather than demanding, “PUSH!”, we can empower a woman by saying, “Let your body open...breathe the baby out...you are strong...you are safe...” The long-term effects of those words are immeasurable.

- Jacquie Munro, Vancouver Doula